How to Keep Your Audience Engaged on Social Media: Step-by-step

You spend hours on copy and design to get a social post ready to be engaged and connected with. You check your engagement hours later only to find one of the most frustrating parts of social media – there’s no engagement. It’s a hard pill to swallow because not only is it costly, but you may also be disheartened by the lack of engagement. That’s why we put together a step-by-step guide you can use to connect with your audience in a way that will open up conversations, build relationships, and ultimately drive your business.

But What Is Social Engagement? Why Does It Matter?

Social media engagement is how many people interact with your content. For example, engagement can include metrics like: comments, favorites, shares, or mentions. It’s a great way to measure if your content is actually something your audience wants. The more compelling the content, the more likely your posts will get more reach. By building these positive, thoughtful relationships with your audience, you can ultimately impact your bottom line.

You may be posting great content but getting low engagement or you may be lucky and getting great engagement metrics. But there’s no maximum when it comes to engagement – there’s always room for improvement.

The Rockstarr Guide to Increasing Engagement on Social Media

1. Analyze Your Current Engagement

One of the first steps will be analyzing your current engagement, so you know where you’re starting from. Check out how many followers you currently have, comments, shares, and whatever metrics are important to you. Track these numbers regularly to see if your strategy is working.

2. Choose Your Strategy

Because there’s no one size fits all when it comes to developing a social media marketing strategy, this step will take some time. Think about your brand, your marketing goals, your industry, and what you have to offer. Once you better understand your strategy, you can identify the right channels.

3. Know Your Audience

Your content will depend on your audience. It won’t make sense to use emojis and slang when your audience is older. Understanding your audience will guide you in deciding what platforms to use, when to publish, the type of content, and your voice. You’ll increase your reach simply by knowing your audience and the best times to schedule your posts.

4. Create Valuable Content

Here is where you really start thinking and developing great content that engages conversation. Don’t simply broadcast to them because social media is not a one-way street. Build a trusting relationship by becoming a valuable resource for content that they need and addresses their pain points. You may have to experiment, analyze, tweak, and then repeat to find your winning formula.

5. Be Smart With Your Hashtags and Stay on Top of Trends

Don’t know what to post? Check out trending topics and hashtags. But, be smart because you don’t want to appear like you’re joining in the conversation for clout. Using hashtags appropriately can double your engagement rate.

6. Encourage Sharing and Conversations

Being proactive and reactive is important when trying to open up conversation and keep it going. Be reactive and respond to your direct messages, comments, and mentions. Be proactive and engage in conversation about you, but haven’t mentioned you directly. Instead they could’ve used common nicknames or misspelled your name. Make sure to use tags when mentioning people to inspire an engaged community.

7. Write Strong, Eye-Catching Headlines

Encourage your followers to click on a link by making the headline catchy and emotional. Keep it simple and stay away from industry-speak because you want it to be accessible to everyone. Test headlines in tools that can score how strong they are. How to, list, and question headlines tend to get the most engagement.

8. Visuals! Visuals! Visuals!

Posts that have relevant images or videos get 94% more views than content that does not have images at all. Whenever possible, use video – it’s the most engaging type of content, regardless of social media platform. Facebook users alone watch 100 million hours of video every single day. Also, to keep things fresh for your audience, update your profile photos regularly.

9. Always Listen and Respond Quickly When Appropriate

The expectation of people is that once they post on social media, the response should be immediate. Responding quickly to people can increase customer satisfaction and save you the time and money of having them call into your customer service line. Our tip is to have a customer service guidebook ready filled with pre-composed answers to common questions you receive. Even though it seems contradictory to showing your human side, it’ll help you in the long run so you don’t have to waste time chasing down answers.

10. Show Your Human Side

People want to know that there’s a real life human on the other side. It could be as simple as signing off on your posts, or responding to people in a human way.

Remember to measure the engagement so you know what works and what doesn’t. It’ll also help you prove the ROI on your social media strategy and identify the trends that increase engagement. The result will fuel your sales and is a great way to build a community of life-long fans of your brand. 

The Marketing Snapshot You Can’t Afford to Miss

Are you ready to uncover the hidden roadblocks holding your business back? Rockstarr & Moon’s instant marketing snapshot report delivers the clarity you need to boost your brand and skyrocket growth—fast.

In just seconds, you’ll receive a powerful, personalized report breaking down your digital presence. From website performance and SEO rankings to social media impact and beyond, we reveal:

  • What’s working: The strengths you can capitalize on.
  • What’s missing: The gaps holding you back.
  • What’s next: Actionable insights to fuel your success.

Why waste time guessing when you could be growing? Get the tailored insights you need to dominate your market and outshine the competition—all in the time it takes to grab your coffee.

Ready to level up? Enter your info now for your instant, no-strings-attached marketing snapshot. The results are waiting—are you?

Get on the VIP List

Subscribe to The Jam Sessions

Gain access Rockstarr marketing tips and insights with The Rockstarr Jam Sessions, our exclusive newsletter with actionable marketing strategies you can start applying today.

Ready to ignite your marketing? You can’t start a fire without a spark.

The Spark promotes powerful marketing strategies. With each article, you will experience Rockstarr marketing with tangible tactics you can start using today.

What’s the best marketing advice you’ve ever received?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s the best marketing advice you’ve ever received?“Stop waiting for perfect. Just get your message out there.” Why This Advice is a Game-Changer Too many businesses overthink marketing. They spend months tweaking their website, overanalyzing social media posts, or waiting for the “right time” to launch a campaign. Meanwhile, their competitors are out there taking...

 How can businesses market effectively on a tight budget?

Hey Rockstarr team -  How can businesses market effectively on a tight budget?You don’t need a massive budget to market effectively. What you do need is consistency, creativity, and a strategic approach. Where to Focus Your Marketing Budget Leverage Organic Social Media – Post high-value content on LinkedIn, Instagram, or Facebook (wherever your audience is). Start an Email List – It costs...

What’s your take on influencer marketing?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s your take on influencer marketing?Influencer marketing can work, but most businesses do it wrong. Paying someone with a big following to promote your product won’t automatically lead to sales. Why? Because audience size doesn’t equal trust. Why Most Influencer Campaigns Fail Wrong Influencer Choice – Just because someone has a large following doesn’t mean they have...

What’s the most underrated marketing channel?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s the most underrated marketing channel?SMS marketing. Why SMS is a Goldmine ✅ 98% open rates (compared to ~20% for email)✅ Immediate engagement – Most texts are read within 3 minutes✅ Higher conversion rates – SMS gets 5-10x more responses than email Best Ways to Use SMS Marketing Appointment & Order Reminders – Reduces no-shows and increases sales. Exclusive...

How do you market without sounding salesy

Hey Rockstarr team - How do you market without sounding salesy?Most people hate being “sold to,” but they love solutions. The key to marketing without sounding pushy is to shift from selling to serving. How to Sell Without Sounding Like a Salesperson ✅ Lead with Value – Provide useful insights, case studies, or actionable advice before making an offer.✅ Use Storytelling – Instead of saying...

What’s the role of AI in marketing today?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s the role of AI in marketing today?AI is a game-changer, but it’s not a replacement for human connection. What AI Can Do in Marketing ✅ Automate Repetitive Tasks – AI can handle email sequences, chatbots, and social media scheduling.✅ Generate Content Faster – AI tools like ChatGPT can draft blog posts, emails, and ad copy.✅ Analyze Data & Personalize – AI can...

What’s the best way to grow an email list?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s the best way to grow an email list?If you want people to join your email list, you need to give them a damn good reason. Why Most Email Lists Don’t Grow The Lead Magnet is Weak – A boring “Sign up for updates” button won’t cut it. No Clear Value Proposition – If people don’t see what they’re getting, they won’t subscribe. Too Many Barriers – If your sign-up process...

What’s one outdated marketing tactic businesses should drop?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s one outdated marketing tactic businesses should drop?Cold outreach without research. Sending generic cold emails, LinkedIn DMs, or calls with zero personalization is a waste of time. Today’s buyers are smarter—they can spot a copy-paste message from a mile away. Why It Doesn’t Work People Hate Spam – If your outreach isn’t tailored, it’s going straight to the...

How do you know when to pivot your marketing strategy?

Hey Rockstarr team - How do you know when to pivot your marketing strategy?If your marketing isn’t producing leads, sales, or engagement, it’s time to pivot. But too many businesses either wait too long or panic and change direction too soon. The key is knowing when a strategy truly isn’t working versus when it just needs tweaking. Signs You Need to Pivot Your Leads Have Dried Up – If your...

What’s the fastest way to get more leads?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s the fastest way to get more leads?The fastest way to get leads isn’t ads or SEO—it’s referrals. Why Referrals Work So Well Instant Trust – People trust recommendations from friends & colleagues. Higher Conversions – Referral leads close 3-5x faster than cold leads. Low Cost, High ROI – You don’t have to spend money on ads to get them. How to Get More Referrals...

What’s the best way to build authority in an industry?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s the best way to build authority in an industry?Want to be seen as the go-to expert in your industry? You need to show up, share value, and get your name everywhere. The Authority Building Formula Content + Consistency = Visibility Speaking + Teaching = Credibility Results + Social Proof = Trust 5 Ways to Become an Industry Authority Post Valuable Content Regularly...

What’s one marketing tool every business should use?

Hey Rockstarr team - What’s one marketing tool every business should use?Every business needs a solid CRM (Customer Relationship Management) system. If you’re still tracking leads in spreadsheets or trying to remember follow-ups in your head, you’re losing money. Why a CRM is a Game-Changer No More Lost Leads – A CRM keeps track of every contact, conversation, and deal in one place. Automated...