How to Write Attention-Grabbing Website Headlines That Convert

Writing headlines is hard.

A great headline can get you clicks, which can lead to higher conversions. But, you’ll come across more bad headlines than good – especially on social media. You have seconds to make an impression before people leave your website. So, we broke it down for you in this step-by-step guide of how to create attention-grabbing headlines.

How to Write the Perfect Headline

When writing copy, the headline matters a lot. Because they’re the first line your customers read, it’ll create the first impression that either draws them in or pushes them away. If your headlines don’t draw the attention of your readers, they probably won’t continue reading and they’ll go somewhere else.

Create headlines by thinking about the following rules of thumb often called the four U’s:

  • Your headlines should be unique: Stand out from the crowd with copy that doesn’t come off as boring and robotic.
  • Your headlines should be ultra-specific: Provide your readers with enough information to let them know if they’ll want to continue reading. You can use specific numbers and data in your headline to create a bigger impact.
  • Your headlines should convey a sense of urgency: Compel your readers to keep reading so they don’t miss out.
  • Your headlines should be useful: Communicate the value and benefit to your customers immediately. Focus on the value you bring to people and avoid using ‘salesy’ language because a hard sell is going to not motivate users to keep reading. Instead, focus on incorporating relevant keywords to help your Search
  • Engine Optimization (SEO). (Don’t forget to deliver on your promise too or else you’ll come off as click-bait!)

Here are some examples that use the four U’s to create strong attention-driven headlines:

  • 5 Data-Backed Strategies That Will Get You More Mailing List Subscribers
  • 10 Simple Steps to Write a Small Business Plan for Beginners
  • 7 Blogging Mistakes That Cost Me. How Many Are You Making?
  • 5 Steps I Took to Write My First Book (And How You Can Do It in 4 Steps)
  • How to Get 100,000 Readers For Your Blog
  • How to Optimize Your Welcome Email to Make the First Sale
  • 10 Effective Saving Tips For Those Who Want Extra Cash
  • Top 10 Places to Find Winning Marketing Campaign Strategies
  • 14 Secrets for Keeping Visitors on Your Website

3 Easy Headline Strategies

You may not be a copywriter, but writing a great headline doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Copywriters use these winning strategies when creating headlines that convert: social proof, a threat, or a gain headline.

1. Social Proof (Piggyback) Headlines

95% of people age 18-34 read reviews before they make their purchasing decisions. Consumers want to see that other people like that product or service before they spend their money. So, by putting social proof in your headlines, you can make it easier for them to make that decision.

Here are some great examples:

  • 10,000 Digital Marketing Agencies Used This App to Optimize Operations
  • Why Project Managers Are Obsessing Over This Project Management Tool
  • $10k+ Drop Shippers Are Shipping This Automation Tool and Here’s Why!
  • 5 Tips to Write Blog Introductions From a Copywriting Pro

2. Threat Headlines

A threat headline isn’t threatening your users but shows them how to avoid pain points by reading your content. Some examples would be:

3. Gain Headlines

The formula is pretty simple: benefit + promise: your gain headline. What is the benefit of clicking on the social post, and what’s the promise you’re making to them in return for clicking.

Simple Ways to Improve Your Headlines

Besides the obvious of making your headline stand out by being prominent with the right color, font, and graphics, there’s a lot of simple ways you can improve your headlines. Here’s just a few of them.

  • Add the words “How to” to your title.
  • Communicate a time frame for when people will receive the benefit they’re promised in your headline.
  • Add fascination that’ll stop the scroll and have your reader’s saying, “That’s interesting.”

The headline alone can make or break your level of success when it comes to your content. It sets the tone for your copy. With an attention-grabbing headline, you can boost your traffic and ultimately your sales. With the wrong headline, you may be left wondering what went wrong.

Get on the VIP List

Subscribe to The Jam Sessions

Gain access Rockstarr marketing tips and insights with The Rockstarr Jam Sessions, our exclusive newsletter with actionable marketing strategies you can start applying today.

Ready to ignite your marketing? You can’t start a fire without a spark.

The Spark promotes powerful marketing strategies. With each article, you will experience Rockstarr marketing with tangible tactics you can start using today.

How to Unlock Your Agency’s Potential with Rockstarr & Moon’s Growth Amplifier

Consulting agencies often struggle with differentiating themselves and reaching their target audience. Things get even more challenging when referrals are drying up, and the sales pipeline gets tight. That’s where Rockstarr & Moon’s Growth Amplifier steps in—it isn't your regular marketing tool; it's a bespoke approach and system designed specifically for consulting agencies aiming to...

Spark | Duluth Trading Co.

Company: Duluth Trading Co. What sparked our interest: Duluth Trading is a brand that celebrates the spirit of hard work and reliability. They craft clothing for men and women who aren't afraid to roll up their sleeves and dig into the day's work. Duluth Trading's gear is top-notch, made to last, and produced right in the heart of Wisconsin. Their secret recipe? They focus on the real stuff...

25 Marketing Ideas for Local and Small Businesses

As a small business owner, you know marketing is vital to reaching new customers and growing your business. Implementing marketing ideas for small businesses is sometimes complex due to limited resources and budget, and not knowing where to start or which tactics will provide the most significant impact can take time. But we have you covered. We’ll break down 25 effective marketing ideas you...

5 Local SEO Tips for Small Businesses and Consulting Agencies 

Are you a local business owner or leader looking to expand your company's online presence? Local SEO for small businesses can be a powerful tool for increasing visibility in search engine results pages, and it’s become even more important with the growth of mobile phone use. With effective local SEO strategies, you can attract potential customers, building your online authority without...

5 Essential Tips to Generate Leads for Your Small Business

Are you struggling with lead generation for your small business? Are you searching for an effective way to increase interest in your product or service and drive more sales? Don't worry, you're not alone. Generating qualified leads is a challenge many business owners and leaders face, but it doesn't have to be daunting. Strategies like referral programs and email marketing can be great when...

How to Set Goals for Consulting Agencies and Executive Coaches?

As an executive consulting professional, it is essential to set effective consultant goals to be successful. Developing achievable objectives helps you define success and how your agency can progress toward achieving it. Whether managing an established consulting business or starting from scratch, setting adequate goals allows you and your team to stay on track by ensuring everyone is focused...

How to Add Value to Your Customers? 5 Tips for Consulting Businesses

As a consulting agency owner, finding how to add value for your customers and ensure they're satisfied with each solution you provide is essential. With customer expectations growing and competition becoming more intense, consulting businesses have to consider how they can differentiate themselves—which is why, more than ever, adding real value that exceeds customer’s needs is crucial. Here...

10 Essential SEO Tips for Professional Services Firms 

Are you wondering how to maximize your web presence and increase leads for your professional services firm? It's no secret that SEO is a great place to start, but trying to learn the ins and outs of a search engine optimization strategy can be overwhelming. To make things easier, we've compiled a list of 10 essential SEO tips specifically tailored for professional services firms. From...

How to Approach Email Marketing for Small Businesses

Are you looking for a cost-effective way to reach your target customers and keep them engaged with your business? Email marketing for small businesses is the answer if you seek a cost-effective way to reach and engage your target customers. It has always been one of the top conversion tools, allowing businesses of all sizes to stay connected with their audiences and promote their offerings...

How to Track Marketing Efforts? KPIs, Tools, and Strategies

With the rise of digital marketing, tracking your marketing efforts has become more critical than ever before. Monitoring and analyzing data provides invaluable insight into your campaigns' success (or failure), allowing you to make data-driven decisions to improve your marketing strategy. However, with so many metrics and tools available, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. That’s...

10 Tips to Build a Small Business Marketing Strategy

Building a successful and sustainable business isn't easy; it requires hard work and careful planning. A solid small business marketing strategy is essential for marketing-savvy entrepreneurs looking to give their business an edge, but how do you create one that's effective and efficient? Fortunately, ten essential tips can help you craft a comprehensive marketing strategy for your small...

What Is B2B Marketing and How to Boost It for Your Business?

Are you looking to increase sales and expand your target market? With the rise of technology, business-to-business (B2B) marketing is becoming increasingly important. B2B marketing is a powerful tool that uses business relationships to promote products or services. It has seen explosive growth in the past decade and can effectively reach larger markets. Usually, the way to boost your...